The Right Way to Use Plumber’s Putty vs. Teflon Tape

May 2, 2025

If you’ve tackled a plumbing project at home, you’ve probably come across two common sealing products: plumber’s putty and Teflon tape (also known as thread seal tape). Both play an important role in preventing leaks — but they’re not interchangeable. At Charlotte Plumbing, we often see DIY jobs go sideways simply because the wrong sealant was used in the wrong place.

Here’s a breakdown of when to use each one — and how to use them the right way.

What Is Plumber’s Putty?

Plumber’s putty is a soft, pliable sealant used to create watertight seals around non-pressurized plumbing parts — most commonly in sinks, drains, and faucets. It remains flexible over time, making it ideal for areas that may need to be adjusted or removed later.

When to Use Plumber’s Putty:

Sealing the base of a faucet to the sink

Installing sink strainers or drain assemblies

Mounting pop-up drain stoppers in bathroom sinks

When Not to Use Plumber’s Putty:

On pressurized water lines

On threaded pipe connections

With materials like granite or marble (as it may stain — use a stain-free version if necessary)

How to Use It Properly:
  1. Roll the putty between your hands to form a rope about the thickness of a pencil.

  2. Press it into place around the fixture base or flange.

  3. Tighten the parts together — the excess putty will squeeze out.

  4. Wipe away any excess for a clean finish.

What Is Teflon Tape?

Teflon tape is a thin white tape used to seal threaded pipe joints, especially on pressurized lines. It helps prevent leaks by filling small gaps in the threads and creating a tighter seal as connections are tightened.

When to Use Teflon Tape:

On shower arms and showerheads

On threaded water supply lines

On pipe fittings for water heaters, dishwashers, or washing machines

When Not to Use Teflon Tape:

On compression fittings (which seal with a nut and ferrule, not threads)

On flare fittings

Inside fixture seals where a gasket or rubber washer is already present

How to Use It Properly:
  1. Clean the threads of the male fitting.

  2. Wrap the tape clockwise (same direction the fitting will turn) 3–5 times around the threads.

  3. Press the tape into the threads for a snug fit.

  4. Tighten the connection securely.

Common DIY Mistakes to Avoid

Using plumber’s putty on pressurized fittings: It won’t hold — and leaks are almost guaranteed.

Applying Teflon tape backward: If wrapped in the wrong direction, it can unravel as you tighten the fitting.

Skipping sealants entirely: Even high-quality parts can leak without the right sealing method.

If you’re unsure which to use — or if a leak keeps coming back — it may be time to bring in a professional.

Call Charlotte Plumbing for Expert Repairs and Installations

The right sealant makes all the difference between a watertight fix and a persistent drip. At Charlotte Plumbing, we help homeowners across the Charlotte area get plumbing repairs done right the first time. Whether you’re replacing a faucet, sealing a drain, or installing a new appliance, our experienced team is just a call away.

Need help with a leak or plumbing project? Contact Charlotte Plumbing today — we’ll seal the deal with expert service and guaranteed peace of mind.

Charlotte Plumbing: How to Fix a Loose Faucet Handle
June 9, 2025
Dealing with a loose or wobbly faucet handle? Charlotte Plumbing walks you through quick DIY steps to tighten it up and restore proper function—no plumber needed.
Charlotte Plumbing: Troubleshooting Garbage Disposal Smells
June 9, 2025
Is your garbage disposal smelling bad or making strange noises? Learn how to identify and fix common disposal issues with help from Charlotte Plumbing.
Diy fixes for a slow-draining bathtub by charlotte plumbing
June 9, 2025
Discover simple DIY solutions to fix a slow-draining bathtub before calling a plumber. Charlotte Plumbing shares expert tips to clear buildup and keep drains flowing.
Charlotte Plumbing: Shower Head Leaking? Here’s What to Do
June 9, 2025
Is your shower head leaking nonstop? Discover the causes and DIY tips to stop the drip—or call Charlotte Plumbing for fast, expert repairs in the Charlotte, NC area.
What to do when you need to unclog a toilet without a plunger
June 9, 2025
Need to unclog a toilet without a plunger? Charlotte Plumbing shares safe, effective DIY methods using items you already have at home. Learn step-by-step solutions from local pros.
May 2, 2025
A running toilet is more than just an annoyance — it’s a steady drain on your water bill and a potential sign of wear inside your tank. One of the most common causes? A worn-out toilet flapper. At Charlotte Plumbing, we help homeowners across the Charlotte area resolve small issues before they turn into costly problems. If you’re the DIY type, here’s a straightforward guide to replacing a toilet flapper and stopping that constant running.
May 2, 2025
Clean, safe water is something every homeowner wants — and a whole-home water filtration system is one way to get it. But are these systems right for everyone? At Charlotte Plumbing, we install and service water filtration systems across the Charlotte area, and we’ve seen firsthand the benefits (and limitations) they can bring. Here's a breakdown to help you decide if a water filtration system makes sense for your home.
May 2, 2025
Chemical drain cleaners might seem like an easy fix for a clogged sink or slow-draining tub, but they come with risks that homeowners should understand before reaching for the bottle. At Charlotte Plumbing, we believe in educating our customers so they can make safe, informed decisions about their home’s plumbing. Here’s what you need to know about using chemical drain cleaners — and when it's best to call in the professionals.
April 4, 2025
When it comes to home improvement, plumbing upgrades aren’t always top of mind—but they should be. At Charlotte Plumbing, we’ve helped countless homeowners in the Charlotte area invest in smart, value-adding upgrades that not only improve daily comfort but also boost resale potential. Whether you're preparing to sell or just want to modernize your home, plumbing improvements can make a lasting impact.
April 4, 2025
As temperatures begin to drop in the Charlotte area, it’s essential to protect your home’s outdoor plumbing from freezing. At Charlotte Plumbing, we often see costly damage caused by burst pipes and neglected winter prep—most of which could be avoided with a few proactive steps. If you’re unsure how to get your plumbing ready for cold weather, this guide will walk you through the basics of winterization.
More Posts